March 30, 2007

« Go to previous entry | Home | Go to next entry »

The Myth Revisited

Reiner Holzemer


Magnum in Motion, a traveling festival with films by and about Magnum photographers as well as several essays by the agency's multimedia division, is moving on from Guadalajara to Thessaloníki, Istanbul, New York and Melbourne. It began its worldwide tour at the Berlinale Film Festival in February where it opened with the documentary "Magnum Photos: The Changing of a Myth." The film maker, Reiner Holzemer, shares his experience of revisiting his 10-year-old documentary in the company of Magnum photographers.

Robert Capa shooting film during the Spanish Civil War in October 1938. Gerda Taro.Robert Capa shooting film during the Spanish Civil War in October 1938. Gerda Taro.

I arrived in Berlin Friday afternoon. In the evening, my film “Magnum Photos: The Changing of a Myth“ was going to be shown at the Berlin Film Festival 2007. I expected no big event, no big movie theatre and no crowds because the film is almost 10 years old. The only advantages that I saw in this late screening were an invitation to Berlin, a nice hotel room and a festival pass, which would give me access to free tickets.

I was not nervous at all when I entered the Berlinale International Film Festival office. Caroline Walke, the assistant for the special screenings series, said “Hello, good to see you! I have great news. The screening tonight is sold out and all the Magnum photographers, who are in town, will come to see the show. Elliott Erwitt is here, Dennis Stock, Martine Franck, Thomas Höpker, Raymond Depardon (the Oscar winner!) and Donovan Wylie. Your film will be the opening of the Magnum in Motion series.“ Now I became nervous, when I left the office.

I remembered the pressure that I felt when I was shooting the film in 1998 and the sickness that came along with the long editing process.

At that time, I was a nobody in the international world of documentary film making. I had only made a few more or less successful documentaries for German and French TV. One was about the photographer Thomas Höpker, who is a member of Magnum in New York. He told me that Magnum was going to celebrate its 50th anniversary in 1997 and that it would be important to make a film about the renowned agency which was founded by famous photographers like Henri Cartier-Bresson, Bob Capa and two others.

Now I sat in Berlin, opening “Magnum in Motion” with my documentary film. The theatre was packed and Thomas Höpker gave a nice and short introduction before the screening started, saying that the Magnum photographers trusted and liked me and therefore they allowed me to take a closer look at the agency and its well known photographers. I smiled and the light went out.

During the screening, I realized all the mistakes I had made. I don’t want to go into details. It would embarrass me. It is a horror trip when you watch a film which you made 10 years before. There is such a huge gap between then and now in the quality of your work. I felt ashamed.

After I had finished the film in 1998, I had sent a copy to most of the Magnum photographers. The reaction was as controversial as the agency is. Some liked it, because they felt that the basic idea of the agency was communicated in the film. Others did not like it, because it was too long or just because they were not in it. It is hard to satisfy 50 different people with one film. I tried my best to show Magnum as it appeared to me in the late 90s, as an outstanding group of artists with the need to adapt to a changing market. All these thoughts and memories came back to me while I was watching my film.

After the light went on in Berlin I felt a bit like René Burri, when he became a member of Magnum. His first assignment was to photograph the shooting of an Ingrid Bergman movie in Paris. When he entered the studio, she kissed him. Magnum had delivered this experience to René. I wasn’t kissed by anybody in Berlin, but I thought, thank you Magnum for these wonderful experiences!

Magnum in Motion dates:
Thessaloníki International Film Festival: April 19 - April 25
Istanbul Modern: May 4 - May 13
Film Society Lincoln Society Walter Reade, New York: May 30 - June 7
Melbourne International Film Festival: July 25 - August 12

Posted in Understanding the trade | RSS feedCategory RSS feed

E-Mail this | Print | Add to Add this post to: del.icio.us Furl digg Spurl Yahoo MyWeb

« Go to previous entry | Home | Go to next entry »

To top


Reader comments (6)

RSS feedSubscribe to this article's comments via RSS

Reiner,

At the time I felt a bit sorry for you with you camera in the "lion's den". Must have been stressful times, and we certainly could have made things a little easier for you then.
Oh, and I'd love to have a DVD of the movie (which I saw only once)...

Take care

John

Comment posted by John Vink on March 30, 2007

Reiner,

I own a VHS copy. I love the film especially for its interview and "in-the-field" scenes with Luc Delahaye.

Best wishes,

Davin

Comment posted by Davin on March 30, 2007

Where could I view this film? I've recently seen quite a few films on photographers, war photographers, city of photographers or on the border (on reuters photographers, sorry, if the title is wrong) and have always been interested in the way in which the information is conveyed and pieced together (documentary is a broad umbrella term, considering the narrative possibilities nowadays).

Thanks and congratulations on your success (gratuliere zum Erfolg, wie man auf Deutsch sagt!)!

A young aspiring one

Comment posted by Lam on April 2, 2007

I did not saw the film but i must comment about the expression: "It is hard to satisfy 50 different people with one film."
how can someone do that? "they" are so different. some are crazy, some are like ZEN style.
Anyway, congratulations for your work. hugs

ps:Can you guys put the film on the web? thanks

Comment posted by Túlio, Fábio on April 4, 2007

Reiner, this sounds like a very interesting film. Could you let us know how to get hold of a copy? Thanks.

Comment posted by James Cox on April 6, 2007

Dear all,

Reiner asked that you email him if you want to buy a copy. Send the email to blog@magnumphotos.com and we'll forward it to him.

Comment posted by Blog Editor on April 12, 2007

Post a comment

(required)

(required but not published)

(required)

RSS feedSubscribe to this article's comments via RSS

Or browse the Archive for all articles and sections.

Notifications:

Sign up to get notified via E-Mail of every new article posted on the Magnum Blog.

RSS feedSubscribe to the Magnum Blog RSS feed



Access To Life

The Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria and Magnum Photos teamed up to produce a major photographic commission.
In Access To Life, eigth Magnum photographers portray thirty people in nine countries around the world before and four months after they began antiretroviral treatment for AIDS.

Visit the Access To Life website

More articles:


Cornell Capa 1918-2008
Martin Fuchs

Cornell Capa was born Cornell Friedmann to a Jewish family in Budapest. In 1936 he moved to Paris, where his brother Andre (Robert Capa) was working as a photojournalist. He worked as his brother's printer until 1937, then moved to New York to join the new Pix photo agency. In 1938 he began working in the Life darkroom. Soon his first photo-story - on the New York World's Fair - was published in Picture Post.


The Khmer Chronicles / Issue Nr 9: About ethics and corruption rankings
John Vink

There was a time when Cambodia was not even listed on Transparency International's Corruption Perception index. But Cambodia is more and more part of the...


Larry Towell's Indecisive Moments Documentary
Martin Fuchs

Larry Towell is a photojournalist who travels reluctantly and only when the subject really matters. But if he travels he does so to really follow his subjects around for a long time, he tells a story from a very humanistic point of view adding his own unique perspective. From 1993 to 2006 he photographed in Israel and Palestine, producing an immense body of work. Two amazing books, "Then Palestine" and "No Man's Land", arose out of this work.


Auto Crazy
Martin Parr

China. Beijing. The Beijing Motor Show. 2008. © Martin Parr/Magnum Photos I am in a taxi, stuck in a big traffic jam. I am...


Find more articles in the Archive.

Categories:

Behind the image
What happened as the shutter clicked

Behind the project
The bigger story behind a project

Conversations
A loose series of conversations with photographers, editors and industry professionals

Educational
Educational content concerning Magnum workshops and other offers

From the field
Stories from around the world

Inside Magnum
Stories from the people who work at Magnum

Magnum Books
Stories around Magnum books

Miscellaneous
Miscellaneous blog articles and announcements

Photo of the week
One photo every week and almost no text

Understanding the trade
From magazines to galleries, photographs' many lives

Recent Comments:

A short conversation with the new Magnum nominees Olivia Arthur and Peter van Agtmael (21)
Comment by tomé

Cornell Capa 1918-2008 (29)
Comment by Alexander Kouznetsov

The Access to Life Campaign (15)
Comment by bram antareja

Larry Towell's Indecisive Moments Documentary (10)
Comment by glenn capers

Magnum Magnum: Chien-Chi Chang by Bruce Davidson (8)
Comment by gerard crewdson

Authors:

Alec Soth, Ann Tornkvist, Ben Shneiderman, Bjarke Myrthu, Bruce Davidson, Bruce Gilden, Chien-Chi Chang, Chris Steele-Perkins, Claudia Guadarrama, Claudine Boeglin, Constantine Manos, Daniel Power, Elliott Erwitt, Frank Smyth, Geert Van Kesteren, Inge Bondi, Jörg M. Colberg, Jessica Dimmock, John Vink, Jonas Bendiksen, Magnum Photos, Malaria No More, Martin Fuchs, Martin Parr, Martine Franck, Matthew Murphy, Meagan Young, Pablo Inirio, Paolo Pellegrin, Patrick Zachmann, Peter Marlow, Pia Frankenberg, Reiner Holzemer, Simon Wheatley, Stephen Bulger, Stuart Franklin, Artprice.com,

For more information on every author visit the Authors page.

Blog Home | Archive | Authors | Links | Blog Policy

© 2008 Magnum Photos. All rights reserved.
Duplication of any material on this site without author's consent and attribution is expressly prohibited.

RSS feedSubscribe to the Magnum Blog RSS feed